59+ Fire Island Lighthouse Holiday Rentals & Private Villas

Find Family-Friendly Holiday Rentals in or near Fire Island Lighthouse

Discover more than 59 StayAndPlay accommodations in Fire Island Lighthouse, perfect for your golf getaway. StayAndPlay offers luxury golf resorts, private villas, and vacation rentals with everything you need for a relaxing escape near Fire Island Lighthouse, NY.

Whether you're seeking upscale golf-front resorts, private luxury villas, spacious vacation homes, or family-friendly golf retreats, we can help you find the ideal stay. Our rentals feature top-tier amenities such as private pools, fully equipped kitchens, outdoor patios, hot tubs, and Wi-Fi, ensuring your group enjoys a comfortable and memorable stay.

Planning a group golf trip to Fire Island Lighthouse? StayAndPlay guarantees a unique and unforgettable experience with plenty of options for families, large groups, or private rentals for long or short stays. Explore our Fire Island Lighthouse pet-friendly golf accommodations and easily book your dream golf resort or villa rental in Fire Island Lighthouse with StayAndPlay.

Show more
Show less

Frequently Asked Questions About Fire Island Lighthouse Holiday Rentals

There are a lot of options in Fire Island Lighthouse. If you plan on staying in the Fire Island Lighthouse area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the top Holiday Home Rentals in Fire Island Lighthouse:

There are many holiday rentals available in Fire Island Lighthouse; however, here are a few of the most popular holiday homes listed in Fire Island Lighthouse on our website:
At StayAndPlay most of our places to stay are perfect for families. Check out the complete list of holiday homes in Fire Island Lighthouse to find one that works for you.
Yes, there are 59 self-catering family homes and holiday rentals in Fire Island Lighthouse.
There are more than 59 luxury holiday homes in or near Fire Island Lighthouse, according to 2025 data from StayAndPlay. Consider these homes for your next holiday:
Yes, there are 59 pet friendly rentals that are available in Fire Island Lighthouse.